There are two ways to decide which tax year a transaction belongs to. Since April 2024 the simpler one is the default for sole traders and most landlords. You now have to opt out, not in.
The difference in one line
| Cash basis | Traditional (accruals) | |
|---|---|---|
| Income counts | When the money arrives | When you invoice |
| Expenses count | When you pay | When you're billed |
Invoice a client on 2 April 2027 and get paid on 20 April. Under cash basis that's income in 2027/28. Under traditional accounting it lands in 2026/27. A year earlier, and taxed a year sooner.
Why cash basis is the sensible default
- You don't pay tax on money you haven't received. The single biggest advantage, and it matters most when clients pay late.
- Your bank statement is your accounting record. No debtors ledger, no accruals, no year-end adjustments. Which is exactly why it suits MTD's quarterly rhythm.
- Nothing to reconcile. What went through the account is what goes on the return.
For a landlord with two properties or a sole trader invoicing a handful of clients, cash basis is almost always the right answer. It is also what MTDFox assumes.
When traditional accounting is the better choice
- You carry significant stock. Cash basis takes no account of unsold inventory, which can distort profit badly in a trading business.
- You're seeking finance. Lenders often want accounts prepared on the traditional basis.
- Your business is complex: multiple entities, long project cycles, work in progress.
Limited companies cannot use cash basis at all. Neither can partnerships that have a company as a partner.
Switching between the two
You choose on your tax return each year, so you're not locked in. But you cannot double-count or drop a transaction in the changeover: an invoice already taxed under the old basis must not be taxed again under the new one. Switching in a year with large unpaid invoices is the case worth taking advice on.
Landlords: it's the default for you too
Property businesses use cash basis by default unless rental income exceeds £150,000, or you elect otherwise. It combines with the rest of the landlord rules exactly as you'd expect. And note that mortgage interest is still not an expense on either basis. Section 24 is a separate restriction, and it applies whichever way you count.
The practical takeaway
If you're reading this to decide, you almost certainly want cash basis: it's the default, it's simpler, and it matches how MTD wants you to keep records anyway. Choose traditional accounting only when you have a specific reason, stock, lending, or an accountant who has told you to.
Related: what landlords can claim and MTD for sole traders.
Stuck on MTD?
Ready before the deadline?
MTDFox keeps your records in HMRC's exact quarterly format and sends the update for you, about ten minutes a quarter. Free during the beta, no card needed.
Official sources
This guide is general information, not tax advice. Rules current as of . Always check GOV.UK for the latest position.